This week, Pitchfork dropped their list of the
100 Best Indie Rock Albums of All Time,
so unfortunately for me, I felt the need to go deep on every album in there. I made some decent progress.
Now, you might ask, what even is indie rock? I don't really know. And now that
I'm looking at the list again, they also pose the question.
The way I'd define it, combined with the Pitchfork definition, is rock music
that pushes the boundaries of what rock is, maybe by dabbling in other genres or
using different instruments or production techniques. Very vague. Then
Pitchfork added the qualification that it must be released by an indie label
(literally any label other than Sony, Universal, and Warner). It gets trickier
when there are dozens of labels who market themselves as "indie" but really
they're just a subsidiary of one of the majors.
I think the indie-label qualification is important, though. You've got to have
a lot more grit to make it big on the indie path, with much less funding and
marketing, and a lot more risk. The indie rock albums that made it big here
had to take big swings, and lots of times that leads to more adventurous music.
The album that's been sticking with me the most, from the list, is this one:
↗
1998
Moon Pix
Cat Power
slowcoreindie folk
It comes in at #13 (wow! I was thinking it was in the top half of the list till
I just checked again). I hadn't listened to this before, and the placement is
hard to argue with, honestly. It's slow, haunting, the perfect album for an
overcast fall, maybe slightly rainy, day.
The story behind the album is crazy as well. Apparently Chan (Cat Power) was
living in a remote farmhouse in South Carolina, planning her retirement from
music. One night, she woke up in a night terror where there were dark spirits
everywhere in the house, which I guess was a sign to her to start writing
music. Or it was just her muscle memory at that point. What she wrote that
night became this album.
The craziest thing to point out here: listening to it, it sounds exactly like
the indie folk/indie pop from the early 2010s. I can't believe this came out in
'98.
My favorite song is
Metal Heart. It
starts with a plucking electric guitar, layered vocals, and lyrics that are
slipping away in real time. It takes its sweet time just filling up space
before the drums roll in, all building to a very resolute, hooky chorus. The
meaning of the song could go a million different directions.
Cross Bones Style
and American Flag
are more rhythm-forward. Cross Bones Style puts a steady and driving drum fill
under the hypnotic guitar line that makes it sound even more modern. I would
kill to have seen this one live.
American Flag is an unexpected opener. Apparently Chan wanted more texture on
the song, so she brought a copy of
Paul Revere by the
Beastie Boys to the studio and had its drumbeat reversed and mixed straight
through the middle of the song. It sounds really different from the rest of the
album, but it works, and it sets the tone well.
Colors and the Kids
is on the other side of the spectrum. It's just Chan and a piano. The
lyrics feel monolithic, like I need to sit with the song for a long time and
let them, and the way they're sung, soak in. Generally it feels like it's about
learning to return to simplicity to find fulfillment and happiness when life
gets complicated and confusing.
The album is fantastic, way ahead of its time, and certainly feels unlike
anything I've listened to before.
Also, you should check out
Pitchfork's list
to see if anything piques your interest, or if there's anything there you
recognize. They did a good job with it, imo!
Listening to a lot of
this album this week.
It's not a hot take to say Fiona has a perfect discography, but this album
doesn't get enough love.
I'm also reminded this is one of her best songs (instrumentally, I might say
best?). The way the piano and drums seem to chase each other (maybe to
symbolize the relationship it's about?), while also moving through different
scenes of blocking each other, flowing together, and going manic.
If listening habits stand, I'll probably be writing more about this album next
week. Fugazi is a top 10 band for me, easily, and this album is them redefining
post hardcore, the genre they defined in the first place.
The political corruption this song is about seems sometimes like it'll be a
problem forever:
The elected are such willing partners
😬
And the mix of this song, from the placement of the drums to the guitar tone and the way more and
more instruments get involved as it progresses, is a cool illustration.